How to Move Your Finger in Tashahhud—You Move it Up and Down a Lot in a Manner that Can Hardly Be Seen

by The Albaani Blog


Questioner: In some of your tapes we heard that moving the [index] finger in the tashahhud is not done by raising and lowering it, i.e., [but should be done by moving it] from the right to the left, so we implement this, walhamdulillaah, but the people ask us what the proof for that is?

Al-Albaani: How do you implement it?

Questioner: Ya’ni, I move my finger from the right to the left.

Al-Albaani: Who told you that?

Questioner: One of your tapes, O Shaikh.

Al-Abaani: No, you’re mistaken.

Questioner: What is the correct way?

Al-Albaani: The correct way is that you move it in its place, not to the right and left, in other words, you raise it and lower it but in a manner that can hardly be seen, understand?

Questioner: Understood, O Shaikh, understood.

Al-Albaani: As for moving it the right and left then this has crept in among you from your old madhhab, or from the madhhab of some of you in Algeria and Morocco and those countries on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea, i.e., the Maaliki madhhab, they are the ones who do what you mentioned …

Questioner: In [your book] Sifatus-Salaatin-Nabee, you mentioned that when Imaam Ahmad was asked whether he pointed with his finger in the prayer he said, ‘Yes, intensely.’ Intensely, what does intensely mean here? The speed or what?

Al-Albaani: That is it, ya’ni, a lot.

Questioner: A lot?

Al-Albaani: Yes.

Questioner: Alhamdulillaah.

Al-Hudaa wan-Noor, 564.

Also read this post.